
New York
The 8 Best Pizza Places in New York City
The best pizza in New York, according to local chefs and food writers.
New York is known for having the best pizza in the country, offering everything from classic New York slices to Neapolitan masterpieces. In this guide, we slice into the best pizza places in NYC, providing you with everything you need to know in order to enjoy a great pie. From the innovative toppings at L'Industrie Pizzeria to the authentic trattoria atmosphere of Zero Otto Nove, and the classic slices at Bellucci Pizza, these establishments are landmarks in the city's culinary landscape, each offering some of the best pizza in town. All picks in this article are based on recommendations from World of Mouth experts, such as pizza blogger Adam Kuban, restaurateur Will Guidara and food writer Joshua David Stein. So, whether you're a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor craving a slice of the city, get ready to discover the best pizza in NYC.
L’Industrie Pizzeria is a bustling spot in Williamsburg known for some of the best pizza slices in New York. Their paper-thin crusts, made with natural fermentation and high-hydration techniques, keep regulars coming back. Grab a seat at the bar or enjoy the lively sidewalk patio for a relaxed, neighborhood vibe.
Recommended by
This renowned pizza joint delivers a delightful blend of classic and creative pies.When it comes to pizza in New York City, L’Industrie reigns supreme. Nestled in the vibrant Williamsburg area, this renowned joint delivers a delightful blend of classic and creative pies. What sets them apart is their mastery in crafting paper-thin crusts using natural fermentation and high-hydration techniques.Don't miss out on the burrata slice. A beautiful interplay of temperatures as the cool burrata perfectly balances the tangy tomato sauce. If you're not able to score a seat at the bar, you can enjoy your slice in the bustling ambiance of the spacious sidewalk patio.
Zero Otto Nove is a neighborhood spot on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, known for its Neapolitan wood-fired pizza and housemade pasta by Chef Roberto Paciullo. It offers a laid-back setting in the heart of what many call New York’s real Little Italy. The friendly vibe makes it a comfortable place for both locals and visitors.
Recommended by
The true Little Italy of New York is in the Bronx. Take a stroll down Arthur Ave, visit over 100 years old Madonia Bakery, have pizza in Zero Otto Nove, shop grocery in the Arthur Avenue Retail Market and have a beer in the Bronx Beer Hall that is located inside. Cin Cin!
Mama’s TOO! on the Upper West Side serves up crisp, flavorful pies that many say are among the best in the city. The relaxed setting and steady quality have made it a favorite stop for pizza lovers in New York.
Recommended by
This was the best slice of pizza we've ever had (of that style of pizza, we don't want to offend any Italians!)Almost caramelized, super crunchy, lots of flavor!This one was a Hot Soppressata with honey pizza.
Bellucci Pizza blends New York–style and New York–Neapolitan traditions, serving thin and crisp slices made with fresh, quality ingredients. The shop takes pride in its carefully crafted crust and consistent flavor, creating a welcoming spot for anyone who appreciates a good slice. Its down-to-earth atmosphere and focus on simple excellence make it an appealing neighborhood favorite.
Recommended by
Bellucci is making consistently excellent thin, crisp, and flavorful slices in this tiny shop.World-class slice pizza somewhere between New York–style and “New York–Neapolitan” (aka coal-oven pizza) made by pizza obsessive Andrew Bellucci, the pizza maker who helped resurrect NYC icon Lombardi’s in the 1990s. Bellucci is making consistently excellent thin, crisp, and flavorful slices in this tiny shop off the beaten path in Queens.
Louie’s is an old-school pizzeria in Queens that’s beloved by locals for its comforting, time-tested style. Though it’s tucked away in a neighborhood known for other cuisines, it welcomes regulars and new faces alike with its laid-back atmosphere. The menu also includes non-pizza options, giving everyone something to enjoy.
Recommended by
This might be my favorite square in Queens. My favorite pizza here is the “grandma” slice or pie.If Louie’s were in Manhattan, it would have press out the wazoo and lines down the block, but it’s in a part of Queens better known for amazing Thai food, so it flies somewhat under the radar. My favorite pizza here is the “grandma” slice or pie. Get a pie, so you have some to take home with you (it freezes well and reheats even better). This might be my favorite square in Queens. Louie also serves an array of non-pizza dishes, which admittedly I haven’t explored that much, but I’ve heard the ribeye steak is a sleeper hit here.
L&B Spumoni Gardens is an old-school Italian spot in Brooklyn that’s been around since 1939. It has a relaxed, counter-service feel and has earned a loyal following over the decades. The welcoming atmosphere and long-standing tradition make it a local favorite for casual, year-round visits.
Recommended by
A Brooklyn institution for good reason with tremendous Sicilian pies.When it's the summer and you're fresh from a dip in Coney Island, when it's the winter and you need comfort, the pies at L&B are unbeatable. We're a pizza city but I haven't found anything that beats the pillowy dough, the sweet tomato sauce and the mozz of a classic Sicilian square at L&B. (During the summer, the move is to sit outside with your pizza then order the Italian ice. During the colder months, the newly remodeled dining room is plenty welcoming.)
Fini Pizza is a laid-back spot in Brooklyn that stays true to its New York roots while adding a slight twist. Owned by Sean Feeney, it focuses on straightforward flavors rather than fancy extras. It’s a welcoming place that prides itself on being genuinely local and delicious.
Recommended by
My favorite tomato pie in the city. A NYC slice joint with a twist.Fini Pizza in Williamsburg is owned by Sean Feeney and is just awesome in many ways. It’s your NYC slice joint, but with a twist. They’re not trying to be fancy or innovative, just delicious and New York proud. Their tomato pie is the best in the city.
Looking for more restaurant recommendations to
New York
? Get the World of Mouth app for free and discover expert recommendations to over
3,000
destinations, curated by top chefs, food writers and sommeliers. From street food to fine dining and well known institutions to hidden gems, World of Mouth is your ultimate insider's guide to the world's best restaurants.
Meet more experts
Discover more

